I am writing this as an Arts Activist and NOT A MEMBER OF ANY ORGANIZATION.
NOW…………
I would like to be the first Arts Activist to express my complete sadness at the disgusting behaviour portrayed by the EDRS (Economic Development and Recreational Services) officials at a public meeting on Friday the 15th April 2011.
It is with great shame and an embarrassment, that the Arts is still treated in the manner that it was treated on Friday the 15th April.
The meeting was set to begin at 12h30. The Artists were already seated when in walked Mrs. Shoba, Vaughan Japtha, Brent Jonas, Lulama, Kym and Mandy to set up for the meeting. No Agenda given prior. No preparatory work before the meeting and clearly a disorganized office at display. (I BLAME YOU MR. SISWANA AND MELANIE FOR NOT BEING THERE) and we received no clear direction on why we were called into the meeting;
At the ‘meeting’ we ‘discussed’:
The Cultural Policy
- It still amazes me that even though we all agree that the 2005 Cultural Policy Framework is still relevant today, but it is still not funded. So, it ‘WILL DIE’ a very slow and painful death
- The Lotto Funds can be easily spent within that agreed framework, we all agree, BUT….
- Where is this Policy going?
- Whilst other Metros were at the DAC conference to discuss amongst other things, the issue of Cultural Precincts… who was representing me? When will a report on this be made available?
- How quickly everyone jumped on the first plane to go to Cape Town to “negotiate” a contract with ESP.
- Who is the development partner alongside ESP?
- A Three year contract and then WHAT after that?
ESP Africa and the ‘Music Festival’
- Even after Rashid has expressed that he would like to go to the Artists himself and speak directly with them. He was told, ‘that won’t be necessary’, and
- This as a shock after Vaughan Japtha was instructed by Mrs. Shoba during the meeting to give a presentation about the ‘Music Festival’ that he clearly did not prepare himself and did say that Brent Jonas is leading on this. Brent Jonas who decided to disrespect the Artists and sat way at the back by the door before deciding to leave (Since WE as Artists had nothing better to do)
- Vaughan did express that he did not write the report and that Brent is the one in charge, BUT… Brent Jonas refused to do or say anything.
IronMan
- For the first time in the history of Iron Man in the Metro, the front page of the Herald did not have the face of the Arts all because an official in a disorganized environment did not do his job. Nothing must be said. Artists must remain quiet and wait for the next ‘bone’ that will be thrown at them.
- The Dance groups who have been called on meetings about this event and the programme they will be part of, Dance groups who have to dig deep into their empty pockets to come to town for a meeting about what they have been promised (Why the officials never go where the Artists are and leave their air-conditioned offices, beats me to this day). The Artists were called only on Friday morning to be called yet onto another meeting where they were expected to spend their last cent only to be told that they will not perform (But not told that the reason they will not be performing is because someone on Salary every month did not do his/her job to ensure that families who have nothing are fed)
- A kind reminder, that even though those Artists never signed an agreement with Municipality….all of them together stand a good chance of sueing that office for BREACH OF PROMISE and that IS a VERBAL CONTRACT and they are all witnesses to each other’s case
- Find a mechanism and pay those Dancers the money that’s due to them…it’s theirs…it’s not their fault you messed up your relationship with the organizers of Iron Man. DO NOT MAKE YOUR PROBLEM THEIRS.
The R11m and now R12m Township Arts Development Programme
- We buy a newspaper every morning with the hope that we will bump into the Tender brief that Mrs. Shoba said it will be on the papers on the 1st week of April….. WE ARE STILL WAITING, as the deadline for the Lotto is STILL end of July…
Bay Film Festival and the Inner City Music Festival
- The report that has been sent to the Lotto is a complete blatant LIE!!! I have a copy of it.
Mendi Bottle Store and Motherwell Art Centre
- If you looking for a disgrace of complete failure by the EDRS Officials, then these two dreams should be on top of the list
- Motherwell Art Centre left to decay (on Taxpayers account). Even after Mr. Siswana on the meeting of the 7th February boldly announced that ‘They have found about R23m to complete the Centre’. This after six years of nothing. WE WAIT!!!!!!
- Mendi Bottle Store should be renamed “Dream”. Mrs. Shoba on the meeting of the 15th April 2011 announced that there has been movement now with Bisho since all the money for this project has been there for all these year. Who needed to do what to get this done?
- Mr. Siswana at a meeting on the 7th Feb 2011 announced that ‘They have found +-R20m to complete this” WE WAIT!
- From a Metro well known for non-service delivery you would thing this Department would jump at the opportunity to correct the imbalances left by those who abused, humiliated and exiled our great Artists…..It seems the same is still in existence.
At the End of the Meeting:
- Mrs. Shoba found it entertaining to answer her cellphone in the middle of an Artist’s comment, while
- Brent Jonas and others were enjoying the sunlight outside,
- As Vaughan started packing up his belongings and walking out in the middle of meeting.
I know this for a FACT:
- Nothing will be done……UNTIL.
- No one will be held accountable…..UNLESSS
- No media coverage of the appauling behaviour by the Municipality….UNLESS……
- The continued abuse of the Arts will continue…..UNTIL.
Now, take this message and delete it….drop it in your recycle bin….then forget about it….after all…these are just Artists….they know no better
Oyama Vanto
Alan Straton
Latest posts by Alan Straton (see all)
- Chocolate, Banana and Bubblegum Milkshake Syrups for the School Holidays - 19 November 2026
- Trusting Trusts Offers Plain-Language Reviews of Older Trusts - 19 November 2026
- Sticker Papers Pro Sets Out When Outdoor Print Needs Polymeric Film - 19 November 2026
- B2B Expos Hands Buyers One Indexed Supplier Pack After Each Supplier Day - 18 November 2026
- Haemodialysis Technical Services Explains Its Loan Units for Renal Units - 18 November 2026

Another sad example of the blatant abuse of power. The ANC lead Municipality as well as government is completely reactive, there is absolutely no pro-activeness at all.
It seems that it isn’t bad enough that the Municipality has squandered “our” ratepayers money on nonsense, now they are squandering struggling artists money as well, promising a job and then taking the offer away due to the EDRS ineptitude. Urghhhh, then the ANC thinks that they have a chance by saying things like the poor have been neglected in CT, what bollocks!
And you wander why theatre in Port Elizabeth is dying a death? Lack of vision, lack of effective management and lack of knowledge. Those who have the abilities have been sidelined in favour of political correctness. It is sad now looking from the outside as to how far behind the city has fallen in this regard. The lights are slowly going out……….
I was also at the meeting, and would like to remain anonymous.
I walked out as I was so disgusted to hear an official from Recreation and Culture present a report which stated that Nelson Mandela Bay has no flagships and no outstanding Museums!
On the other hand, I understand that disillusionment has crept in with the officials working at Recreation and Cultural Services – due to what seem to be internal battles they are grappling with….