• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • MyPE Copyright Terms
    • Authors
    • Deals
  • Info
    • Accommodation
    • Classified Adverts
    • Directory
    • Essential PE Numbers
    • Flight Schedules
    • Forex Converter
    • PE’s Online Radio Stations
      • Algoa FM
      • Bay FM
      • iFM
      • Kingfisher FM
      • MannMade Radio
      • Madibaz Radio
      • Umhlobo Wenene
    • Podcasts
    • Shipping
    • Street Map
    • Tides
    • Ward Details
    • Ward News
    • Weather
  • Contact
    • Advertising on MyPE
  • Submit
    • Blogger
    • 5 Quick PE Questions
    • Entertainment
    • Events
      • Add your Port Elizabeth event
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Lost and Found
    • Movers and Shakers
    • News Article
    • PE Videos
    • Photographs
    • Recipes
    • Traffic Hooligan
    • Say NO
  • Dam Levels
  • Advertorial
  • Business
  • NMBRA
  • NMB Rates
MyPE

MyPE

Community Business Directory, Event Listings, News and Views from Gqeberha, Nelson Mandela Bay

SSA move to Presidency may lead to further secrecy, Parliamentary oversight crucial

13 August 2021 By Alan Straton

Dear Editor

The least surprising of the changes made to the Cabinet was the doing away with the State Security Agency (SSA). There had to be severe lessons seen to be taught, and the Ministers of State Security and Defence were the ones who caught it in the neck.

As expected, the President’s close ally, Police Minister Bheki Cele, was left unscathed, despite all accounts that of the three security cluster entities, the South African Police Service (SAPS) performed by far the worst.

Naturally all fingers are now pointing to the National Police Commissioner, General Kehla Sithole, who should probably be counting up his pension benefits which may have to come into play in the near future.

By far the biggest move was to simply do away with an entire Ministry – the State Security Ministry – and to sweep it and its Deputy Minister under the Presidency. Indeed, the President claimed that there were many countries in the world which have the Intelligence agencies (in our case, the State Security Agency, Crime Intelligence and Defence intelligence) answering directly to the President.

The President’s move follows the catastrophic failure of the Security Cluster in predicting (flatly denied by the-then Minister of State Security), and preventing (SAPS members were either invisible, or stood back and watched as billions of rands worth of stock and infrastructure went up in smoke) an uprising that killed 337 people, and all but destroyed the KwaZulu-Natal economy and greatly damaged that of Gauteng.

Heads had to roll, for this and so many other catastrophic outcomes by tepid Ministers.

We have a history – laid out in shocking technicolour detail in the High-Level Review Panel report on the SSA – of the previous President using the Intelligence cluster for himself and himself alone.

Is President Ramaphosa strong enough to withstand the siren call of such? This move puts us in serious jeopardy of replaying the catastrophe that was Jacob Zuma and the Security cluster, and the increase in the secrecy stranglehold swirling around this group – rather than dealing with the unnecessarily excessive secrecy as condemned in the High-Level Report.

Will there come a time when our rights to freedom of expression may become politically inconvenient and labelled a threat? This is a very real possibility.

The President has claimed that there are countries which place Intelligence directly under head of the country – obviously we will be asking him which countries these are. Additionally, we welcome the reliance on Dr Sydney Mufamadi (author of the High-Level Report) as security adviser. However, we can’t be seen to be putting the future of South Africa at risk of such a crucial entity as the Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence (JSCI) once again being used as a private beach for a President.

An obvious move to allay such fears would be the establishment of a Joint Standing Committee on the Presidency – a dedicated committee which has oversight power over all the affairs of a Presidency.

State Security now joins other entities under the Presidency, which currently runs the structures on investment, infrastructure, project management and Operation Vulindlela.

Indeed, it has come full circle and is back where it started, under a Deputy Minister for Intelligence serving at that time under the Justice Minister. Once again it is no longer a stand-alone Ministry, but this time directly answerable to the President.

Despite the High-Level Report, the security cluster – specifically State Security – is still a morass of issues wrapped in a cloud of confusion and lead by the dominant faction of the day. It seems the Matthews Inquiry report of 2008 and the High Lever Report of 2018 together, have achieved very little indeed.

To quote: “Excessive secrecy gives rise to suspicion and fear and this reduces public support for the services. In a democracy, unlike a police state, the services must rely on public cooperation rather than coercion to be successful.”

Shifting State Security under the President is merely shifting it under the President. It won’t decrease the levels of secrecy, nor decrease the public suspicions.

Regards

Dianne Kohler Barnard MP
Spokesperson on National Intelligence

Go On – Share the Gqeberha Love!



Gqeberha’s Latest News and Events can be accessed on MyGqeberha.com.

The following two tabs change content below.
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Flickr profileMy Pinterest profile

Alan Straton

Chief Cook, Bottle Washer and Broom Mechanic at MyPE
Passionate about Port Elizabeth and definitely NOT packing for Perth. Alan's ethos is epitomised in the words of Nelson Mandela; "I have fought against white domination and I have fought against black domination. I have cherished the idea of a democratic and free society. If need be, it is an ideal for which I am prepared to die." See more articles by Alan.
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Flickr profileMy Pinterest profile

Latest posts by Alan Straton (see all)

  • Can Too Much Screen Time Increase Childhood Obesity? - 20 November 2026
  • Chilla Brings Mango, Watermelon and Blueberry Bubble Tea to South Africa - 20 November 2026
  • Short Festive Runs Still Need Readable Batch Codes, Says Pinetown Coding Ink Supplier - 20 November 2026
  • Africa Exhibitions Brings Freestanding Heritage Shows to Libraries and Museums Where Walls Stay Untouched - 20 November 2026
  • Pretoria East Renal Clinic Publishes a What-to-Bring List for Specialist and Dialysis Visits - 20 November 2026

Filed Under: Community Tagged With: MyGqeberha

Footer

RSS Straton Electrical

  • Open Cycle Gas Turbine Usage
  • Flattening the curve – What Every Solar Installer Needs to Know
  • Why you shouldn’t leave a charger plugged in when not in use
  • How do I check if an Electrician is properly registered in South Africa?
  • Easy Electrical Troubleshooting for Humans
  • Water – If You Cannot Measure It Then You Cannot Manage It
  • Tips To Survive Loadshedding
  • Eskom’s Top 50 Electricity Saving Tips

RSS MyPE Business News

  • NMBBC On Budget 2025
  • Leading Business Minds Set to Headline Chambers Annual General Meeting
  • Bay of Opportunity Portal
  • Bay of Opportunity Ambassadors Programme to Promote the Bay and Attract Investment
  • 6 Decades of Trucking
  • Thermal Camera Installed at Redhouse Substation
  • Finalist in the 2025 South African Car of the Year
  • Joining hands to create a lasting impact to St Albans Primary School

RSS MyPR Press Releases

  • Can Too Much Screen Time Increase Childhood Obesity?
  • When Logistics Tech Fails, Who Keeps Freight Moving?
  • Grand Theft Auto VI Takes Over Johannesburg With an Immersive Album Listening Experience and Supercar Meet
  • Fatso 98 Closes Out 2026 With Intimate New EP Before I Leave
  • Short Festive Runs Still Need Readable Batch Codes, Says Pinetown Coding Ink Supplier

How you may use MyPE content © 2026 MyPE · Gqeberha, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyPE Ads and Media Kit