As social networking usage grows lawyers are beginning to leverage communications on social networking sites – including Facebook and Twitter – as a source of evidence in court. Tweeters and those posting to Facebook must therefore be fully aware that what they publish is discoverable.
Just as emails are discoverable – and if deleted can easily be traced – caution should be exercised when a person communicates on Facebook/Twitter. Not only is such communications discoverable but may also qualify as a defamatory statement and therefore actionable.
In two court cases in America the communications on MySpace surprised litigants. In the first case a young woman claimed damages for an injury sustained in a car accident. She exaggerated her injuries and was confronted by her MySpace pictures of her skiing in the Swiss Alps. In the second case, an accused in a criminal matter pleaded guilty to aggravated assault with a gun.
At the sentencing stage his attorney in mitigation endeavoured to portray the accused as a peaceful man who had found religion. However, the prosecution found a picture of the accused holding a gun on the accused’s MySpace page as well as his comments.
The photo was used as evidence against the accused.
The message is therefore that the red light should flicker when players on the various networks publish on their page communications which may find its way to court and may be damaging.
Pieter Conradie
Director, Dispute Resolution, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr
Alan Straton
Latest posts by Alan Straton (see all)
- The Countdown On – Mind Matters Is Taking Over Cape Town Before Taking the Conversation Global - 28 September 2026
- BurnesSEO Study Finds South African Small Businesses Invisible in AI Search Results - 28 September 2026
- BurnesSEO Study Finds South African Small Businesses Invisible in AI Search Results - 28 September 2026
- Why Digital Equity Is South Africa’s New Frontier for Women’s Empowerment – By Matebe Chisiza-Asukile and Natasha Mboyisa - 25 September 2026
- New Champions Rise at the 2026 Street Lines Skate Tournament - 23 September 2026
