• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • MyPE Copyright Terms
    • Authors
    • Deals
  • Info
    • Accommodation
    • Classified Adverts
    • Directory
    • Essential PE Numbers
    • Flight Schedules
    • Forex Converter
    • PE’s Online Radio Stations
      • Algoa FM
      • Bay FM
      • iFM
      • Kingfisher FM
      • MannMade Radio
      • Madibaz Radio
      • Umhlobo Wenene
    • Podcasts
    • Shipping
    • Street Map
    • Tides
    • Ward Details
    • Ward News
    • Weather
  • Contact
    • Advertising on MyPE
  • Submit
    • Blogger
    • 5 Quick PE Questions
    • Entertainment
    • Events
      • Add your Port Elizabeth event
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Lost and Found
    • Movers and Shakers
    • News Article
    • PE Videos
    • Photographs
    • Recipes
    • Traffic Hooligan
    • Say NO
  • Dam Levels
  • Advertorial
  • Business
  • NMBRA
  • NMB Rates
MyPE

MyPE

Community Business Directory, Event Listings, News and Views from Gqeberha, Nelson Mandela Bay

Information Bill threatens academic freedom and the ability of universities to performing their functions in a free society

25 November 2011 By Alan Straton

The NMMU Council has noted with grave concern the passing of the Protection of State Information Bill on 21 November 2011 by the National Assembly of Parliament in Cape Town by a majority of 229 to 107 votes. We note that parliamentary process requires the Bill to be forwarded to the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) for its consideration, and hope an opportunity would be afforded to the wider public for further input to ensure the Bill is in line with the basic tenets and requirements of South Africa’s Constitution.

The University Council acknowledges that there is a need to replace the old apartheid secrecy legislation (i.e. Protection of Information Act of 1982) that is clearly not in line with our democratic Constitution. Council also acknowledges that lawmakers have listened to civil society voices in calls for a major revision of earlier versions of the Bill, and also that some progress has been made in improving specific aspects. We note, for example, the insertion of a clause prohibiting ‘classification of information’ being used “to conceal an unlawful act or omission, incompetence, inefficiency or administrative error; restrict access to information in order to limit scrutiny and thereby avoid criticism; prevent embarrassment to a person, organization, or organ of state or agency; unlawfully restrain or lessen competition or prevent, delay or obstruct the release of information that does not require protection under the Act” (Protection of Information Bill, 2011).

However, we believe that the Bill, in its current form, conflicts with other basic tenets on the right to public access to information, notably, Sections 16 and 32 of the Constitution and the Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA) of 2000. In its current form, the Bill fails to provide for a sufficiently strong and clear ‘public interests’ defence clause in relation to information deemed as ‘classified’.  The expansive and open-ended manner in which ‘classified information’ is defined in the Bill is deeply problematic for two reasons. Firstly, it shuts out any critical scrutiny into what constitutes ‘national interests’ and ‘national security’. The danger of this inscrutable use of ‘classified information’ being used to place certain kinds of official practices beyond public scrutiny has most recently been seen, in an extreme form, in flagrant human rights abuses in the name of the so-called ‘war on terror’ as occurring in many parts of the world.

Secondly, despite the Bill’s contention that ‘classified information’ may not be used for purposes of concealing unlawful, corrupt and inept practices by state officials, there is nothing in the Bill that prevents this from taking place as the prerogative of determining if this is the case or not depends on state authorities.

As it stands, the Bill will close off many state practices deemed as ‘classified’ beyond the scrutiny of the public and raise the costs of whistle-blowing on administrative malpractice or corruption.  It will limit the ability of the public – media, civil society and universities – to rationally debate what is in the public interests and what is not. We do not believe that such crucial decisions can only be left in the hands of state officials. The negative impact of the Bill on access to information and freedom of speech poses a direct threat to the role of universities whose role is to speak truth to power. Council agrees with the statement by Higher Education South Africa (HESA) that ‘without access to information the process of knowledge generation is hampered, and without freedom of speech, academic freedoms are placed in jeopardy’ (HESA, 31 August, 2011). Council therefore calls upon Parliament to drastically review these limitations placed on access to information and freedom of speech as contained in the Bill and bring the proposed legislation in line with the promise of our democratic Constitution.

Ronnie Pillay
Chairperson NMMU University Council

Judge Ronnie Pillay
Judge Ronnie Pillay
The following two tabs change content below.
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Flickr profileMy Pinterest profile

Alan Straton

Chief Cook, Bottle Washer and Broom Mechanic at MyPE
Passionate about Port Elizabeth and definitely NOT packing for Perth. Alan's ethos is epitomised in the words of Nelson Mandela; "I have fought against white domination and I have fought against black domination. I have cherished the idea of a democratic and free society. If need be, it is an ideal for which I am prepared to die." See more articles by Alan.
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy Google+ profileMy LinkedIn profileMy Flickr profileMy Pinterest profile

Latest posts by Alan Straton (see all)

  • The Diamond Box Helps Couples Plan a Summer Holiday Proposal Online - 16 November 2026
  • For Holidaymakers on Dialysis, December Planning Starts Now, Says Mbombela Travel Planner - 16 November 2026
  • Blackrock Towing & Recovery Stays on Call for Gauteng’s Festive Season Roads - 16 November 2026
  • Alora Medical Wins National Innovation Awards - 16 November 2026
  • RM Capital Explains How It Pays Suppliers Directly to Get Orders Moving - 16 November 2026

Filed Under: Letters to the Editor Tagged With: nmmu, poib, ronnie pillay

Footer

RSS Straton Electrical

  • Open Cycle Gas Turbine Usage
  • Flattening the curve – What Every Solar Installer Needs to Know
  • Why you shouldn’t leave a charger plugged in when not in use
  • How do I check if an Electrician is properly registered in South Africa?
  • Easy Electrical Troubleshooting for Humans
  • Water – If You Cannot Measure It Then You Cannot Manage It
  • Tips To Survive Loadshedding
  • Eskom’s Top 50 Electricity Saving Tips

RSS MyPE Business News

  • NMBBC On Budget 2025
  • Leading Business Minds Set to Headline Chambers Annual General Meeting
  • Bay of Opportunity Portal
  • Bay of Opportunity Ambassadors Programme to Promote the Bay and Attract Investment
  • 6 Decades of Trucking
  • Thermal Camera Installed at Redhouse Substation
  • Finalist in the 2025 South African Car of the Year
  • Joining hands to create a lasting impact to St Albans Primary School

RSS MyPR Press Releases

  • Concentrix South Africa Recognised for Talent, Innovation and Leadership at CapeBPO and BPESA Awards
  • Mpumalanga School Gets a Major Makeover Through Reinhardt’s Community Upliftment Initiative
  • Winning Koesister Recipe Gets a Festive Rooibos Twist
  • AMN Unveils Multi-Band, Multi Technology Radio Node to Accelerate Low-Cost Telecom Rollouts
  • D’vine Skin & Body Answers the Key Questions About Dermapen Microneedling

How you may use MyPE content © 2026 MyPE · Gqeberha, South Africa | Privacy Policy | MyPE Ads and Media Kit